Law of Assumption from a Catholic Perspective

The Law of Assumption from a Catholic Perspective

The Law of Assumption, often discussed in the context of metaphysical and New Thought philosophies, posits that an individual can bring about desired changes in life by simply assuming that they are already true. This principle, popularized by figures such as Neville Goddard, suggests that personal reality can be shaped by the power of imagination and inner convictions. While this idea might initially seem appealing, it is important to examine it carefully from a Catholic perspective, which offers a rich theological and philosophical tradition that addresses the nature of belief, faith, and the human condition.

Understanding the Law of Assumption

The Law of Assumption essentially states that if a person firmly believes that a certain state of affairs is real, it will manifest in their life. This belief is not merely an intellectual assent but involves a deep conviction that occupies the heart and mind, influencing one's actions and reactions. For proponents of this law, the power of the mind is paramount, and reality is seen as malleable to personal will and belief.

A Catholic Critique

1. Nature of Reality and Truth

From a Catholic viewpoint, reality is objective and created by God; it is not subjectively constructed by our desires or beliefs. The Church teaches that truth is not something we create or assume into existence but something we discover and conform ourselves to. According to the Catechism of the Catholic Church, God is the ultimate Truth (CCC 2465), and our task as human beings is to align ourselves with this Truth, rather than attempting to bend reality to our personal assumptions.

2. Role of Faith

In Catholicism, faith is a theological virtue given by God, which elevates the natural intellect and will, enabling a person to assent to the truths God has revealed (CCC 1814). Unlike the Law of Assumption, which centers on self-generated beliefs, Catholic faith is a response to a divine invitation and is inherently relational, involving trust in God rather than in the power of one’s own mind.

3. Human Dignity and Limitation

The Law of Assumption can be critiqued for its somewhat solipsistic approach to life, potentially leading to egocentrism where the individual becomes the measure of all things. In contrast, Catholicism recognizes human dignity but also human limitation. We are made in the image of God (Genesis 1:27) and are called to co-create with Him within the limits of our nature and vocation. The focus is on cooperation with God's grace, not on becoming the sole architects of our reality.

4. Suffering and the Cross

A critical aspect where the Law of Assumption diverges sharply from Catholic teaching is in its approach to suffering. The Law may imply that suffering results from incorrect beliefs or failure to assume positive outcomes. In Catholicism, however, suffering is a mysterious part of the human experience that can have redemptive value (CCC 1505). Jesus Christ’s suffering on the cross is central to salvation history, showing that suffering is not merely something to be "assumed" away but can lead to deeper union with God.

5. Moral and Ethical Implications

The Law of Assumption does not inherently provide a moral framework; its efficacy is not dependent on the moral quality of the desired assumption. This can lead to ethical ambiguities where the ends justify the means. Catholicism provides a comprehensive moral framework that evaluates both the means and the ends, guided by natural law and divine revelation.

6. Prayer and Divine Providence

Prayer in Catholicism is not merely about assuming or manifesting our desires but is a communication with God, where we align our will with His (CCC 2559). It is about trusting in Divine Providence, which always works for our ultimate good, though it may not always align with our personal assumptions or desires.

Integrating Positive Aspects

While offering critiques, it is also possible to acknowledge elements of the Law of Assumption that can find resonance with Catholic spirituality, albeit in a transformed way:

• Hope and Trust: Catholics are called to a hopeful trust in God’s promises. This resembles the optimistic aspect of the Law of Assumption but is grounded in divine fidelity rather than in personal power.

• Imagination in Prayer: The use of imagination is a legitimate part of Catholic prayer life, as seen in Ignatian spirituality. Imagining oneself in the scenes of the Gospels, for example, is a way to deepen one's encounter with Christ, not to assume control over external reality.

• Realization of Christian Potential: The emphasis on realizing personal potential in the Law of Assumption can echo the Christian call to fulfill the unique vocation God has given each person, always in submission to His will and grace.

Conclusion

In conclusion, while the Law of Assumption emphasizes personal belief as a transformative power, Catholic teaching stresses conformity to God’s will, reliance on divine grace, and the objective reality of truth. The Catholic perspective invites a deeper exploration into the nature of faith, reality, and human purpose, emphasizing a holistic approach that integrates body, mind, and spirit under the sovereignty of God. This approach not only respects human limitations but also dignifies human existence by placing it in relationship with the eternal and the divine.